Should Rob be allowed to join in the bird ID?

I'm not sure that the professionals should join in with this as a) they should know what they are and not need to guess! and b) it would make us go straight to that particular bird without us looking through the books and putting in some effort and thus defeat the object of the exercise.

However, as Rob is a very nice chap and if he really want to play then perhaps he can jump in at the end after most have posted their suggestions?

Am I taking this too seriously?!   Discuss.