ID confirmation on pipits please! :-)

Both shots taken on Isle of Skye, (not great pics as taken with my old camera which had a smaller zoom and lower definition!)

This I think is a rock pipit, as he was on a rocky beach (Talisker Bay) and has the pale eye ring I associate with the rock pipits

Now this one was standing in a small brook, and singing! I'm thinking meadow pipit as it has a creamy 'moustache' going back from its beak down its cheek...

What do you think please?

"All weeds are flowers, once you get to know them" (Eeyore)

My photos on Flickr