One for Seymour

Anonymous
Anonymous

Hi Seymour

Have you got another 'puzzler' for us? I learn so much from having to think about identification and study detail of birds' features.

No problem if you are very busy.

I hope you are feeling better now.

Cheers

Pipit x

  • Right. The genus clue actually rules out Cetti's - Sylviidae is the family but Lesser Whitethroat is in genus Sylvia, with much fewer UK candidates :)

    Besides that, the angle makes it tricky to see wing and tail length clearly, but Cetti's has a super-short primary projection, and this mystery bird's primary tips are clearly long enough to easily cross over each other (this bird has long wings because it is a long-range migrant, while Cetti's is sedentary). Also Cetti's has a stronger face pattern with a pale supercilium extending a little way behind the eye and, yep, paler legs.

    That leaves the mystery bird as a Garden Warbler, with its beady eye in a very plain face and subtle grey neck-sides. So Pipit and Blackbird both got it right :)

    I pronouce Cetti's 'CHETT-ies' :)

  • Anonymous
    0 Anonymous 16/06/2010 15:59 in reply to aiki

    Pesky warblers!!

    Thanks aiki, quite a challenge

    Pipit x

  • Anonymous
    0 Anonymous 16/06/2010 16:07 in reply to aiki

    Thankyou aiki

    I took the Warbler to be a Garden Warbler and not a Cettis as a Cettis has no grey and Cettis has a tail like a thick shovel

    More trival but still an observation - just keeping naming bird parts to sound simple.

    Still only heard a Cettis but not seen one as they like to skulk in the bushes a lot.  They have a powerful set of lungs though. 

    As for a Garden Warbler I saw my first one this time last year at Marston Thrift (local to where I stay and I was with a member of Bedford birders at the time - no names mentioned at all but I am sure he remembers too)

    Regards

    Kathy and Dave