Water or Rock Pipit - Anyone's thoughts please?

Hi there everyone,

My wife are currently spending a week in Shetland and on Sumburgh Head yesterday we noticed this little chap. We're trying to identify him and have whittled him down to either a Rock, Water or Meadow Pipit.

We're leaning towards the scarcer Water Pipit purely on the strength of it's duller and greyer plumage, buff white breast and paler legs (which because of the sun are showing more orange than was natural).

We think the Rock Pipit is darker and has much darker legs.

Would love to know what you guys think?

Thanks everyone

Mark