Commissioner Maria Damanaki has put the catfish amongst the pigeons by suggesting a potential future ban on discarding fish from catches in a reformed Common Fisheries Policy. It's good to start thinking about these things and we welcome the initiative of Commissioner Damanaki. Catching fish that you then throw back into the sea dead is wasteful and immoral. That's the problem - but it isn't clear what is the solution.
I've never been to sea on a fishing boat - I'd quite like to have that experience one day - but I'm prepared to say that I believe that it is a tough life physically and financially. Sitting at a desk or exchanging the odd sharp word with the NFU, as I do, is a much easier life. But fishing is also a fairly crude activity in the sense that you can't see what you are catching (even with all the new technology now available) and the fish don't cooperate by sorting themselves below the waves into single species shoals of one size-class of fish. Dragging a net through the water tends to catch lots of things - some things you want and others you wish you hadn't caught. The unwanted catch may be unpalatable species or baby fish that would be much better left in the sea so that you can catch them later when they are bigger and after they've had babies themselves.
Added to which there have been years of over-fishing, resulting in over-depleted fish stocks and the march of technology means that we are always getting better at finding and catching fish - despite it being a tough life.
A reformed CFP is due to be in place by the 1st January 2013, so the RSPB will be working for radical changes to rectify the unsustainable elements of current fisheries practice. We need to ensure that the reformed CFP is based on ecosystem needs, as fisheries will only have a sustainable future if they operate in a healthy marine environment.
The RSPB is also concerned to see an end to the bycatch and subsequent death of seabirds, turtles, sharks and cetaceans in fishing gears of different types. Later this year, we will be talking to the public about additional ways to ensure the whole marine environment is better protected, for example campaigning to get marine protected areas in place throughout the UK’s seas to conserve important marine wildlife and seabirds.
But there is a twist to this fishy tale and that is that discarding provides free meals for seabirds. For long we have regarded it as an ironic consequence of unsustainable fisheries that some seabird species are booming. Fishing trawlers discarding fish will be surrounded by fulmars, gannets, skuas and gulls cashing in on a free meal. And the UK is the home to most of the world's gannets and great skuas so this isn't a trivial matter.
I'd rather have a properly managed marine environment that is providing a better life for fishermen as well as the marine life under the waves than have lots of seabirds feeding on discarded dead fish, but the world is a complicated place and we need to find solutions that will work at the ecosystem level. So, well done Commissioner Damanaki but there's still a bit of a way to go to produce the solution.
Actually Bassman I think it should be standard viewing in schools, Im working on getting it translated and put in schools in Thailand. Who'd have thought!
Yes JAL. 'End of the Line' - should be required viewing for all those interested in fisheries science.
I'm glad I posted this blog - your comments are great - thank you.
JustAlark - welcome to the RSPB Community and this blog. The end of the line is a great film and a great book - by Charles Clover.
Bassman - you may be right. Thank you for giving me a prod.
JonathnWallace, mirlo, redkite and Carduus - very interesting comments, thank you all.
Fisheries are very hard to police, this kind of legislation is only good if its enforced. As Mark has only recently discussed regarding Hen harriers, the legislation in place does little to disuade their persecution. we still see fox hunting prolific in the UK. What I want to know is how these laws will be enforced.
There is an outstandng documentary called 'the end of the line' which discusses the issues of fisheries very comprhensivley.
Discards are easily solved - and the EU are at least on the way to do that.
The fishing industry has won the battle of persuading everyone that stopping discards is difficult - event you, Mark are taken in! It's a tough life of course, but lets stop pussy footing around an industry that dumps half of its catch, ignores legislation, continually bleets its not their fault and puts barriers in the way of change every step of the way. It employs tiny amounts of people has relatively little impact to the UK economy and punches far above its weight in political influence.
Observers on boats, real time CCTV and GPS etc etc. The EU could stop it all tomorrow and the fishing industry would still go on its weary way and catch a profitable payload. At the moment they are just playing the political game. Methinks they protest too much and their end is nigh - hopefully.